+0
Karma
| Class: | ENST 100 - Environment & Society |
| Subject: | Environmental Studies |
| University: | Illinois Wesleyan University |
| Term: | Fall 2009 |
INCORRECT
CORRECT

|
Utilitarianism/Nature as a resource
-Wilderness Condition
|
Roderick Nash -Nature was wild needed to be tamed, Garden of Eden was natural -Feared because of actual danger (Indians, beasts) and moral vacuum, no laws or civilization to restrain the inherent flaws of humanity -Had to make land useful in order to survive |
|
Utilitarianism/Nature as a resource
-Reclamation Idea
|
John Wesley Powell -Wanted government intervention in order to settle the west and make it inhabitable for humans -Leads to the creation of the US Bureau of Reclamation, make use of nature for the benefit of civilized society -Sees nature by its benefit to humanity, "natural timber lands" (Utilitarian view) -Does note that this land cannot support huge populations because of resource limits |
|
Utilitarianism/Nature as a resource
-Conservation@White House
|
Teddy Roosevelt -Speech about the exploitation of natural resources in danger of exhaustion -Fears America will lose prestige because of its dependence on fossil fuels, being "reckless" -In reaction to Frederick Jackson Turner's The Closing of the American Frontier and his Frontier Theory. -No more frontier, we have reached the boundaries of our country, and thus cannot simply keep moving west when we run out of resources ⢠Argues for conservation of resource, limit use to prolong their existence |
|
Nature as Sublime
-Hetch Hetchy
|
John Muir -Nature = God's country/holy which he captures through his poetic descriptions -Opposing movement to dam Hetch Hetchy in order to provide hydroelectric power for San Francisco after a fire -His actions/death lead to the establishment of the Natural Reclamation Act in 1916 which allows the federal government to preserve certain areas of land |
Koofers.com
|
Nature as Sublime
-Walking and Walden
|
Thoreau -Founder of Transcendentalism-focus on interconnectedness of life and nature -Nature reflects spiritual truths, humans need it to survive -Place of freedom, away from cities |
|
Nature as Sublime
-Winter Creek
|
Kathleen Moore -An escape, place for finding oneself and one's thoughts |
|
Problems with the Sublime
|
Problems: -They still see nature as separate, someplace else -What about ordinary nature? Only worrying about sublime views, not everyday grasses and trees. -People "escape" into nature -Essentially, Cronon's arguments |
|
Anthropocentrism v Ecocentrism
|
o (Human centered vs Environment centered)/ Judeo-Christian vs Native American -Book of Genesis- "Go forth and conquer", be "stewards of the land", "masters" -Separation of humans from nature, duality -Idea of superiority -Native Americans are one with nature, harmonious balance as part of a greater whole -They are just one of the world's species and they actively seek to remain at peace with their surroundings |
Koofers.com
|
Nature as a Commodity
|
o Sea World, using nature to sell products (advertising) -Ex; Images of nature presentations -Nature as sublime |
|
Limits to Growth/Carrying Capacity/Exponential Growth
-Meadows
|
Limits to Growth (1972) -Ran computer simulations with the Club of Rome -5 factors "population, food production, industrialization, pollution, consumption of non renewable resources, analyzed to run simulators -Exponential growth in a finite system -> (Limits will be reached in 100 years, leading to a decline in population and industrial capacity) -Possible to alter these, but we need to change now -> Trade-offs b/w present and future benefits |
|
Limits to Growth/Carrying Capacity/Exponential Growth
-Overpopulation
|
Paul Ehrlich -Author of Population Bomb in 1968 -Based off trip to India, sight of overpopulated cities and the problems it caused -Predicts famine and massive die off within the next 20 years, wars over limited resources, very bleak outlook |
|
Limits to Growth/Carrying Capacity/Exponential Growth
-Carrying Capacity
|
Sandra Postel -Decline of fish, rising affluence, more fish consumption -Arable land isn't as fertile, lower production, less yield or more fertilizer -Not helped by housing development -Pollution and environmental destruction affect carrying capacity |
Koofers.com
|
Problems with Limits to Growth
|
-Doesn't happen -Humans aren't limited by geological boundaries -Development of Green Revolution technologies (increased agricultural production, also needs more resource input, especially water) |
|
Faustian Bargain/Alternative Technologies/Bioremediation
-Causes of Pollution
|
Barry Commoner -Uses IPAT- Environmental Impact (Pollution)=Population x Affluence x Technology developed by Paul Ehrlich, who believed population was the problem -According to Commoner, TECHNOLOGY IS THE PROBLEM -Increase in pollution is not proportional to increase in population or affluence -Change in production to synthetics-fabric, plastic -Petroleum based products -Mode of transportation, cars v mass transit ⢠Non-biodegradable waste, larger input of energy into production |
|
Faustian Bargain/Alternative Technologies
-Bioremediation
|
Von Wedel -Technology is the way to save the environment -Bioremediation- using bacteria to biodegrade contaminants -Biofuels- plant based, clean fuels -Biosolvents- chemicals from vegetable oils instead of petroleum |
|
Problems with Faustian Bargain/Alternative Technologies/Bioremediation
|
-Extremely expensive, not yet widely available -Ethanol/biofuels- plant based fuels that require more input than they produce -Example of a Faustian Bargain- you are losing more than gaining (technology) -selling your soul for infinite knowledge |
Koofers.com
|
Tragedy of the Commons
|
Garrett Hardin -Selfishness and laissez faire lead to a destruction of common property -Ex; overfishing in the ocean, pollution of the air, waste in the waters -Deal by gov't stepping in to make public, or privatize land -Common property resources- classes of resources for which exclusion is difficult to control access (excludability characteristic) -Joint use involves subtractability- each user is capable of subtracting from other users ⢠Population is key contributor to this problem |
|
Problems with Tragedy of the Commons
|
-Assumes market economy -Assumes high population -British land was not destroyed until it was fenced off and divided -Mongolia's cashmere industry, worked fine until forced to privatize -Native Americans |
|
Scarcity Society
|
-Politics of Scarcity- by William Ophuls -Scarcity is root of all political evil, need authoritative political action -Democracy is too slow to deal with problems (Laissez faire capitalism) -Problems of collective action- strong individualism makes us weak as group -No sense of collective good, only self-interest -Ecological mandarins- highly educated gov't officials to make environmental decisions |
|
Problems w/ Scarcity Society
|
-Not possible to remove democracy in America -People are inherently suspicious of large government and gov't intervention |
Koofers.com
|
Administrative Management (EPA)
|
o Regulatory agency spanning the gov't, use of experts, designed to be apolitical -Instruments Used: -Environmental impact assessment- statement of environmental impact for new projects or expansion of gov't agencies -Ban use of certain materials, specify which materials can be used -Standards (fines to enforce compliance) -Requiring the use of certain types of equipment/technology ⢠Mandating certain practices be implemented, ex; EIS |
|
problems w/ Admin. Management
|
-Biased, slow, no clear goals -Benefits of long term goals vs need for short term results -Panglossian principle vs. precautionary principle -When activity raises threat of harm to human health or environment, precautionary measures should be taken even if relationships aren'tt fully established -Burden on producer, not victim |
|
Cost-Benefit Analysis
|
o Principle framework used to make public spending decisions -Maximize net benefits (seen in monetary terms) by comparing the costs of benefits o Problems: -Doesnt factor externalities- (environmental costs, human health costs) -Damage/Costs that are not factored into the production costs of a variety of manufacturing processes (prices dont reflect ecological truth) |
|
Environmental Economics (Cap and trade, tax, contingent valuation) + Ecological Economics (GNP v ANP, steady state society)
|
o Major concern of economists is maximizing output by optimizing efficiency -Creation of honest market to internalize externalities, prices tell "ecological truth" -Mechanisms: o Market incentives- taxes, subsidies -Discharge fees (pay for emitting), congestion fees (pay to enter city to cut down on traffic), rebates (cash for clunkers) o Privatization-people take better care of it if its theirs -Tradable permit system/cap and trade |
Koofers.com
|
Contingent Valuation
|
determine values/costs of environmental damages/practices -Cost of air pollution- factor in medical costs, lost workdays to asthma, cost of smog, cost of rising temperatures |
|
Environmental Justice/Racism
|
by Bullard -Minority areas are targeted because rich white areas will not tolerate that -In search of money and jobs, will take it even if it involves health risks -Grassroots organizations developed, gain support from larger NGO's, gain regional success o Benefit of democracy (right to organize) -Environmental movement shaped by upper class (Cronon) |
|
Enviro Justice
-Mountaintop Removal
|
Julia Fox -Coal has influence in politics -Downside of democracy (lobbying) -Environmental destruction and pollution and people can do nothing because coal controls the government and its laws and policies -Externalities are not factored into the "cheap"electricity provided by coal -Failure of market incentives -Hurts poor classes, (environmental injustice) |
|
ACES
|
o Combat global warming (cap and trade on greenhouse gases) o Promote clean energy (renewable energy + "clean coal") o Increase energy efficiency (buildings and appliances) o Transitioning economy (Creation of jobs, protecting consumer) |
Koofers.com
|
Consumerism/Affluenza
|
o Focus on constantly buying new things -Many of our products are designed to be obsolete or worn down in a few years -Petroleum based products (plastics) or fossil fuels used in production -Non biodegradable -Mall is a cultural ritual, "more malls than high schools" -Advertising and marketing targeted toward age groups -Overexposure in schools, television, everywhere from a young age |
|
Ecological Footprint
|
o Analysis of daily object revealed our enormous ecological impact from consumption and production o American society is responsible for a large portion of our footprint simply because of the average lifestyle |
Koofers.com
Front |
Back |
|
|---|---|---|
| Utilitarianism/Nature as a resource -Wilderness Condition | Roderick Nash -Nature was wild needed to be tamed, Garden of Eden was natural -Feared because of actual danger (Indians, beasts) and moral vacuum, no laws or civilization to restrain the inherent flaws of humanity -Had to make land useful in order to survive | |
| Utilitarianism/Nature as a resource -Reclamation Idea | John Wesley Powell -Wanted government intervention in order to settle the west and make it inhabitable for humans -Leads to the creation of the US Bureau of Reclamation, make use of nature for the benefit of civilized society -Sees nature by its benefit to humanity, "natural timber lands" (Utilitarian view) -Does note that this land cannot support huge populations because of resource limits | |
| Utilitarianism/Nature as a resource -Conservation@White House | Teddy Roosevelt -Speech about the exploitation of natural resources in danger of exhaustion -Fears America will lose prestige because of its dependence on fossil fuels, being "reckless" -In reaction to Frederick Jackson Turner's The Closing of the American Frontier and his Frontier Theory. -No more frontier, we have reached the boundaries of our country, and thus cannot simply keep moving west when we run out of resources ⢠Argues for conservation of resource, limit use to prolong their existence | |
| Nature as Sublime -Hetch Hetchy | John Muir -Nature = God's country/holy which he captures through his poetic descriptions -Opposing movement to dam Hetch Hetchy in order to provide hydroelectric power for San Francisco after a fire -His actions/death lead to the establishment of the Natural Reclamation Act in 1916 which allows the federal government to preserve certain areas of land | |
| Nature as Sublime -Walking and Walden | Thoreau -Founder of Transcendentalism-focus on interconnectedness of life and nature -Nature reflects spiritual truths, humans need it to survive -Place of freedom, away from cities | |
| Nature as Sublime -Winter Creek | Kathleen Moore -An escape, place for finding oneself and one's thoughts | |
| Problems with the Sublime | Problems: -They still see nature as separate, someplace else -What about ordinary nature? Only worrying about sublime views, not everyday grasses and trees. -People "escape" into nature -Essentially, Cronon's arguments | |
| Anthropocentrism v Ecocentrism | o (Human centered vs Environment centered)/ Judeo-Christian vs Native American -Book of Genesis- "Go forth and conquer", be "stewards of the land", "masters" -Separation of humans from nature, duality -Idea of superiority -Native Americans are one with nature, harmonious balance as part of a greater whole -They are just one of the world's species and they actively seek to remain at peace with their surroundings | |
| Nature as a Commodity | o Sea World, using nature to sell products (advertising) -Ex; Images of nature presentations -Nature as sublime | |
| Limits to Growth/Carrying Capacity/Exponential Growth -Meadows | Limits to Growth (1972) -Ran computer simulations with the Club of Rome -5 factors "population, food production, industrialization, pollution, consumption of non renewable resources, analyzed to run simulators -Exponential growth in a finite system -> (Limits will be reached in 100 years, leading to a decline in population and industrial capacity) -Possible to alter these, but we need to change now -> Trade-offs b/w present and future benefits | |
| Limits to Growth/Carrying Capacity/Exponential Growth -Overpopulation | Paul Ehrlich -Author of Population Bomb in 1968 -Based off trip to India, sight of overpopulated cities and the problems it caused -Predicts famine and massive die off within the next 20 years, wars over limited resources, very bleak outlook | |
| Limits to Growth/Carrying Capacity/Exponential Growth -Carrying Capacity | Sandra Postel -Decline of fish, rising affluence, more fish consumption -Arable land isn't as fertile, lower production, less yield or more fertilizer -Not helped by housing development -Pollution and environmental destruction affect carrying capacity | |
| Problems with Limits to Growth | -Doesn't happen -Humans aren't limited by geological boundaries -Development of Green Revolution technologies (increased agricultural production, also needs more resource input, especially water) | |
| Faustian Bargain/Alternative Technologies/Bioremediation -Causes of Pollution | Barry Commoner -Uses IPAT- Environmental Impact (Pollution)=Population x Affluence x Technology developed by Paul Ehrlich, who believed population was the problem -According to Commoner, TECHNOLOGY IS THE PROBLEM -Increase in pollution is not proportional to increase in population or affluence -Change in production to synthetics-fabric, plastic -Petroleum based products -Mode of transportation, cars v mass transit ⢠Non-biodegradable waste, larger input of energy into production | |
| Faustian Bargain/Alternative Technologies -Bioremediation | Von Wedel -Technology is the way to save the environment -Bioremediation- using bacteria to biodegrade contaminants -Biofuels- plant based, clean fuels -Biosolvents- chemicals from vegetable oils instead of petroleum | |
| Problems with Faustian Bargain/Alternative Technologies/Bioremediation | -Extremely expensive, not yet widely available -Ethanol/biofuels- plant based fuels that require more input than they produce -Example of a Faustian Bargain- you are losing more than gaining (technology) -selling your soul for infinite knowledge | |
| Tragedy of the Commons | Garrett Hardin -Selfishness and laissez faire lead to a destruction of common property -Ex; overfishing in the ocean, pollution of the air, waste in the waters -Deal by gov't stepping in to make public, or privatize land -Common property resources- classes of resources for which exclusion is difficult to control access (excludability characteristic) -Joint use involves subtractability- each user is capable of subtracting from other users ⢠Population is key contributor to this problem | |
| Problems with Tragedy of the Commons | -Assumes market economy -Assumes high population -British land was not destroyed until it was fenced off and divided -Mongolia's cashmere industry, worked fine until forced to privatize -Native Americans | |
| Scarcity Society | -Politics of Scarcity- by William Ophuls -Scarcity is root of all political evil, need authoritative political action -Democracy is too slow to deal with problems (Laissez faire capitalism) -Problems of collective action- strong individualism makes us weak as group -No sense of collective good, only self-interest -Ecological mandarins- highly educated gov't officials to make environmental decisions | |
| Problems w/ Scarcity Society | -Not possible to remove democracy in America -People are inherently suspicious of large government and gov't intervention | |
| Administrative Management (EPA) | o Regulatory agency spanning the gov't, use of experts, designed to be apolitical -Instruments Used: -Environmental impact assessment- statement of environmental impact for new projects or expansion of gov't agencies -Ban use of certain materials, specify which materials can be used -Standards (fines to enforce compliance) -Requiring the use of certain types of equipment/technology ⢠Mandating certain practices be implemented, ex; EIS | |
| problems w/ Admin. Management | -Biased, slow, no clear goals -Benefits of long term goals vs need for short term results -Panglossian principle vs. precautionary principle -When activity raises threat of harm to human health or environment, precautionary measures should be taken even if relationships aren'tt fully established -Burden on producer, not victim | |
| Cost-Benefit Analysis | o Principle framework used to make public spending decisions -Maximize net benefits (seen in monetary terms) by comparing the costs of benefits o Problems: -Doesnt factor externalities- (environmental costs, human health costs) -Damage/Costs that are not factored into the production costs of a variety of manufacturing processes (prices dont reflect ecological truth) | |
| Environmental Economics (Cap and trade, tax, contingent valuation) + Ecological Economics (GNP v ANP, steady state society) | o Major concern of economists is maximizing output by optimizing efficiency -Creation of honest market to internalize externalities, prices tell "ecological truth" -Mechanisms: o Market incentives- taxes, subsidies -Discharge fees (pay for emitting), congestion fees (pay to enter city to cut down on traffic), rebates (cash for clunkers) o Privatization-people take better care of it if its theirs -Tradable permit system/cap and trade | |
| Contingent Valuation | determine values/costs of environmental damages/practices -Cost of air pollution- factor in medical costs, lost workdays to asthma, cost of smog, cost of rising temperatures | |
| Environmental Justice/Racism | by Bullard -Minority areas are targeted because rich white areas will not tolerate that -In search of money and jobs, will take it even if it involves health risks -Grassroots organizations developed, gain support from larger NGO's, gain regional success o Benefit of democracy (right to organize) -Environmental movement shaped by upper class (Cronon) | |
| Enviro Justice -Mountaintop Removal | Julia Fox -Coal has influence in politics -Downside of democracy (lobbying) -Environmental destruction and pollution and people can do nothing because coal controls the government and its laws and policies -Externalities are not factored into the "cheap"electricity provided by coal -Failure of market incentives -Hurts poor classes, (environmental injustice) | |
| ACES | o Combat global warming (cap and trade on greenhouse gases) o Promote clean energy (renewable energy + "clean coal") o Increase energy efficiency (buildings and appliances) o Transitioning economy (Creation of jobs, protecting consumer) | |
| Consumerism/Affluenza | o Focus on constantly buying new things -Many of our products are designed to be obsolete or worn down in a few years -Petroleum based products (plastics) or fossil fuels used in production -Non biodegradable -Mall is a cultural ritual, "more malls than high schools" -Advertising and marketing targeted toward age groups -Overexposure in schools, television, everywhere from a young age | |
| Ecological Footprint | o Analysis of daily object revealed our enormous ecological impact from consumption and production o American society is responsible for a large portion of our footprint simply because of the average lifestyle |
© Copyright 2012 , Koofers, Inc. All rights reserved.
The information provided on this site is protected by U.S. and International copyright law, and other applicable intellectual property laws, including laws covering data access and data compilations. This information is provided exclusively for the personal and academic use of students, instructors and other university personnel. Use of this information for any commercial purpose, or by any commercial entity, is expressly prohibited. This information may not, under any circumstances, be copied, modified, reused, or incorporated into any derivative works or compilations, without the prior written approval of Koofers, Inc.