Pros: His material is very informative and helpful, but his teaching style is terrible. He doesn't differentiate between what we need to know and what we don't. In Chemistry knowing how to do problems and understand why you are doing what you are doing, and what to learn is paramount. For my teacher, he has terrible writing and moves too fast through his lecture, (based off the notes), to clarify what his writing says. That wouldn't be too big of a deal for the students up front if he spoke slowly, but he speaks and moves through notes at double the appropriate pace to actually learn the material well. This leaves those in the back half of the auditorium, those with subpar hearing, and those with slow writing methods or brains (i.e.. ADHD & Bipolar people) and those with poor scribble deciphering skills out of luck. About 4/5 of the 500 student class leaves by the end of the semester and this starts very early on in the course. I will actually have to retake this course next semester because it's so poorly taught, that I won't be able to get an A no matter what amount of effort I put forth. I even have a tutor, (and have gone to review sessions with a Chemistry TA), that has taken multiple Chemistry courses, and some of the stuff we work on baffles him. He says that what I work on is too hard for the class that I'm taking. I don't mind the hardness of the course at all. What I have a problem with is the lack of clarity and the lack of empathy for the students taking the course. For a sample chapter he may have a problem set of 40 problems, a chapter problems page with 50-100 problems from the book and their answers in addition to a packet of problems for the chapter not derived from the book constituting another 50-100 problems to do and multiple past exams that have 20-25 questions each. I realize that no one is expected to do all of this, the problem is that the problems are there like we are supposed to do them. There is also no differentiation between more helpful and less helpful practice problems to prioritize our practice or studying. If 100 problems can prepare us for the 20-25 question test, then why do we have as many as 300-400 problems, that take a lot of time even if you do understand them, if all we need is a fraction of that number. If 100 problems can't prepare us for a 20-25 question test, then either the test or problems should be rethought and I think that that should happen in this case as well. I think that that's Silverman's military training coming through, that if 200 problems is good, 400 problems is better. The harder the better in other words. I actually talked with the professor personally and his words to me, paraphrasing here of course, followed like this "The semesters when you have chemistry you should have your nose buried in a chemistry book most of your free time." For an introductory class just covering the basics of a field, this is unacceptable.
Cons: The professor comes from a military background and so he is quite strict and tough on everyone. Supposedly he gets nicer in more advanced courses, which makes me feel even worse about being in his class because then you know he can change. I have had to print off literally 200+ pages for the first four chapters before I realized that some of it was totally unnecessary, but he still had it on our schedule to download and print.
Grading Scale for Fall 2011 is as follows: Best three out of four exams, 50 mins each, 100 points for each exam with multiple choice and/or word problems depending on exam. 6 Quizzes, 10 points each. 5 Homework Assignments (Blackboard) Basically problems sets due a month or so out. Sometimes they overlap and so you have to be an excellent scheduler and time manager to avoid late night disasters with the problem sets. One Final Exam, 140 points. 550 points total.
The below sites will help you in the class and are my favorites.
I received no compensation of any kind for sharing these websites with you.
Sites everyone should know about!
http://www.freedomainradio.com
http://www.psychohistory.com
http://www.calnewport.com/blog
http://www.khanacademy.org
http://www.scotthyoung.com/blog/
www.ted.com/talks
Professor rated by: Chemistry Student on October 19, 2011